Tire Size 315/70r17 vs 285/75r17
Switching from 315/70r17 to 285/75r17 tires is generally a safe change, as the diameter difference falls within the acceptable 3% range. This swap offers a slight reduction in overall tire size, which can impact various aspects of your vehicle’s performance.
The change brings both benefits and drawbacks, affecting factors like ground clearance, fuel efficiency, and handling characteristics.
- Diameter decrease of 1.5% is within the acceptable 3% range
- Width reduction of 9.5% may affect traction and stability
- Smaller sidewall height could impact ride comfort
- Slight increase in fuel efficiency due to reduced size
- Minor speedometer inaccuracy of about 0.31 mph at 20 mph
315/70r17 vs 285/75r17 Chart
Main Difference
The most notable difference when switching from 315/70r17 to 285/75r17 tires is the width reduction of 9.5%.
This change in width is more significant than the diameter decrease and will likely have the most noticeable impact on your vehicle’s performance and appearance.
Fitment Guide
The switch from 315/70r17 to 285/75r17 tires is considered safe and within acceptable limits. The diameter difference is only 1.5%, well within the recommended 3% range.
This means you can make the change without significant concerns about fitment issues or the need for vehicle modifications.
Ground Clearance
Switching to the slightly smaller 285/75r17 tires will result in a minor decrease in ground clearance. The difference is approximately 0.27 inches (6.75 mm), which is relatively small.
For most on-road driving situations, this change will be barely noticeable. However, if you frequently engage in off-road activities or encounter rough terrain, the slight reduction in ground clearance might be more apparent.
In off-road scenarios, the smaller tires may have a minimal impact on your vehicle’s ability to clear obstacles. You might notice a slight difference when navigating over large rocks or deep ruts, but for most off-road enthusiasts, this change won’t significantly alter the vehicle’s capabilities.
Gas Mileage
The switch to 285/75r17 tires is likely to result in a slight improvement in fuel efficiency. The smaller tires have less rotational mass and a slightly reduced contact patch, which can contribute to better gas mileage. While the improvement may be minimal, it could add up over time, especially for those who do a lot of highway driving.
For off-road use, the impact on fuel efficiency will be less noticeable, as factors like terrain and driving style play a more significant role in fuel consumption during off-road adventures.
Aesthetics Look
The change to 285/75r17 tires will give your vehicle a slightly different appearance. The narrower width may make the tires appear less aggressive, which could be a pro or con depending on your personal preferences.
The smaller size might also make the wheel wells appear larger, potentially altering the overall look of your vehicle.
For off-road enthusiasts who prefer a more rugged appearance, the narrower tires might be less visually appealing. However, the difference is relatively small, and many people may not even notice the change without a side-by-side comparison.
Ride Comfort
The switch to 285/75r17 tires may result in a slight change in ride comfort. The smaller sidewall height (reduced by 0.27 inches or 6.75 mm) might lead to a marginally firmer ride, as there’s less tire to absorb road imperfections. However, this difference is quite small and may not be noticeable to many drivers.
In off-road situations, the slightly reduced sidewall height might result in a bit less cushioning over rough terrain. However, the difference is minimal, and most drivers won’t experience a significant change in overall comfort during off-road excursions.
Speedometer Accuracy
The change in tire size will affect your speedometer accuracy, but the impact is minimal. At 20 mph, your actual speed will be about 19.69 mph, a difference of only 0.31 mph. This small discrepancy is unlikely to cause any significant issues in everyday driving situations.
For off-road use, speedometer accuracy is generally less critical, as speeds are typically lower and more variable. The slight inaccuracy shouldn’t pose any problems during off-road adventures.
Handling & Stability
Switching to the narrower 285/75r17 tires may result in slight changes to your vehicle’s handling and stability characteristics. The reduced width could potentially improve steering response and provide a more nimble feel, especially in on-road driving situations. However, the trade-off might be a small reduction in overall grip, particularly during cornering.
For off-road use, the narrower tires might offer better performance in certain conditions, such as mud or snow, where a narrower tire can more easily cut through to find traction. However, in loose sand or gravel, the wider tires might have a slight advantage in terms of flotation and stability.
Durability & Wear
The switch to 285/75r17 tires may have a minor impact on durability and wear characteristics. The smaller size might lead to slightly more even wear patterns, potentially extending the overall tread life.
However, the difference is likely to be minimal and may be overshadowed by other factors such as driving habits, road conditions, and proper maintenance.
For off-road use, the narrower tires might be slightly less resistant to punctures and sidewall damage, but again, the difference is small. Proper tire pressure management and careful driving will remain the most critical factors in preventing tire damage during off-road adventures.
Adverse Performance
In adverse weather conditions, the switch to 285/75r17 tires might offer some slight advantages. The narrower width can be beneficial in snow and slush, allowing the tire to cut through to the road surface more effectively. This could potentially improve traction in winter driving conditions.
For off-road use in muddy or snowy conditions, the narrower tires might perform slightly better, as they can more easily dig down to find traction. However, in deep sand or loose gravel, the wider tires might have a slight edge in terms of flotation.
Noise & Vibration
The change to 285/75r17 tires may result in a subtle difference in noise and vibration levels. The slightly smaller size might lead to a marginal increase in road noise transmission, but this difference is likely to be negligible for most drivers. Vibration characteristics should remain largely unchanged, as the difference in size is relatively small.
For off-road use, any differences in noise and vibration will likely be masked by the more significant impacts of rough terrain and obstacles.
Our Observation
Switching from 315/70r17 to 285/75r17 tires offers a mix of subtle benefits and trade-offs. The slightly smaller size may improve fuel efficiency and handling responsiveness, particularly in on-road scenarios.
However, these gains come at the cost of a minimal reduction in ground clearance and potentially less aggressive appearance. For off-road use, the narrower tires might perform better in some conditions like mud or snow, but may offer slightly less flotation in sand.
Overall, the differences are relatively minor, and most drivers won’t notice significant changes in day-to-day performance. The decision to switch should be based on individual preferences and specific driving needs, as the impact on both on-road and off-road performance is generally minimal.
Will I need to modify my vehicle to fit the new tire size?
No, the diameter difference is within the acceptable 3% range, so modifications shouldn’t be necessary.
How will this tire change affect my fuel economy?
You may see a slight improvement in fuel efficiency due to the reduced tire size and weight.
Will the new tires affect my vehicle’s off-road capabilities?
The impact on off-road performance will be minimal, with slight advantages in some conditions and minor drawbacks in others.
Do I need to recalibrate my speedometer after changing tire sizes?
While there will be a small discrepancy, it’s minimal (about 0.31 mph at 20 mph) and doesn’t necessarily require recalibration.
Will the new tires change how my vehicle looks?
Yes, the narrower width may make the tires appear slightly less aggressive, but the change is relatively subtle.
Related Article
Meet Caitlin McCormack, a Tire Size Expert and Blogger Passionate About Everything Related to Tires. With Years of Experience in the Tire Industry, Caitlin Has Become an Expert in Tire Sizes and Their Impact on Vehicle Performance.